
Check cashers
often move into military communities knowing that service membersą pay
is guaranteed by the federal government.
|
|
Payday lenders
under fire
By JOHN HOFHEIMER and
TOM GALANTE
|
___Payday
advance businesses, like the half-dozen that have sprung up in Jacksonville
over the past few years, prey on people in the military, according to
one ex-GI.
___
"The process sets you up to fail," said the man, who asked not to be
identified.
___
"You borrow money and pay it back on payday, but then you find yourself
with no money again and have to go back. Once you get started, you have
to keep going back," he said.
___
"These kinds of places prey on people who are young and do not have
a lot of experience in financial matters, aren't paid a lot and are
sometimes foolish with their money," he said with a hint of embarrassment.
___
Payday lenders typically make two-week loans to customers at annual
interest rates starting at about 350 percent and running to 1,700 percent
or higher, according to consumer groups.
___
A high credit card interest rate, by contrast, would be about 21 percent.
___
The Arkansas Constitution sets interest rates on consumer loans at 5
percent above the federal reserve discount rate or less. That would
be a current ceiling under 10 percent.
___
Opponents of the payday advance lenders and check cashers say the businesses
flock to neighborhoods of low-income people likely to need ready cash
without a lot of sophistication about their other options, according
to Hank Klein of the Arkansas Federal Credit Union, an organizer of
Arkansans Against Abusive Pay-day Lending.
___
Klein and others say they are out to regulate, if not shut down, these
places, which charge exorbitant interest for loans, secured by the promise
of a customer's next paycheck. Interest rates like these were illegal,
considered usury or loan sharking, until the payday lenders pushed their
own bill through the state legislature in 1999, according to Klein.
LAWMAKER
INTERESTED
___
State Rep. Will Bond of Jacksonville said the General Assembly tried
to crack down on some predatory lending practices last session, and
he would be in favor of taking a look specifically at the payday lending
business.
___
"Obviously, if these things look like high-interest loans, the legislature
would love to take a look at them," he said Friday.
___
He said the legislators should ensure that "people outside the traditional
borrowers market don't get their heads ripped off."
___
"If there's something that needs to be done, I'd be happy to sit down
with anyone," Bond said.
___
Currently, there are six businesses in Jacksonville that either make
payday loans, cash checks for a percentage, or both. At least two of
them are headquartered out of state.
___
In state, W. Cosby Hodges Jr., of Fort Smith, owns two payday lending
business in Jacksonville and another in Sherwood.
___
Hodges has 40 different businesses incorporated with the secretary of
state's office-at least 22 of them for payday lending or check cashing.
Incorporating businesses separately would help insulate Hodges' businesses
one from the other in the case of a legal judgment, according to one
lawyer.
___
About 20 of Hodges' businesses include "American Check Cashers" or "ACC"
in the corporation name. In addition to two in Jacksonville and the
Money Depot, incorporated in Sherwood, Hodges has at least one business
incorporated in Fayetteville, Jonesboro, Fort Smith, Little Rock, North
Little Rock, Conway, Bentonville, Green-wood, Pine Bluff, Rogers, Russell-ville,
Springdale and Van Buren.
___
Hodges was not available for comment.
JACKSONVILLE
LENDERS
___
Hodges' two Jacksonville locations, American Check Cashers, 509 J.P.
Wright Loop Road, and also at 912 W. Main St., make payday loans, according
to the coalition of opponents. Interest on a two-week payday loans is
about 426 percent, according to the study. It advertises loans of as
much as $700, although Arkansas law limits such loans to $400, according
to Klein.
___
That business has affiliated itself with the Mt. Rushmore Loan Company
in Sioux Falls, S.D. Klein said the payday loan businesses operate under
the notion that by associating with an out-of-state bank or savings
and loan, they can skirt such limitations. That tactic is known as rent-a-bank
or rent-a-finance company, he said.
___
Hodges' two Jacksonville locations settled class-action lawsuits, according
to Klein, then converted to a rent-a-finance company.
OUT
OF STATE
___
Other payday loan businesses in Jacksonville are Advance America, 2021
N. First St., incorporated in Spartenburg, S.C., and First American
Cash Advance, 2126 N. First St., incorporated in Cleveland, Tenn.
___
Two check-cashing businesses that don't make payday loans but charge
a percentage include C&B Jewelry Exchange and Loan Co., 84 Municipal
Drive, owned by Charles Myers; and E-Z Check Cashing, 424 W. Main St.,
owned by Tracy Hall.
___
In March 2000, the Federal Reserve board of governors ruled that "regardless
of how the fee is characterized for state law purposes," it was interest
and must comply with the consumer disclosure requirements-effective
Oct. 1, 2000.
___
Arkadelphia attorney Todd Turner has sued often, winning class action
lawsuits. He has filed a lawsuit, currently on appeal, seeking to have
the Check Casher's Act of 1999 declared unconstitutional.
|
EDITORIAL
Bloodsucker
lenders
___"Payday
lenders" and check cashers have settled in this area like so many vultures
picking over road kill.
___
And like vultures disturbed by a passing car, when these operations
are bothered by a lawsuit or unwanted regulation, they back off, then
reassemble in a slightly different configuration. But they are still
vultures, and they are still picking clean their prey.
___
It's no accident that Jacksonville, home of the Little Rock Air Force
Base, is home to six of these operations.
___
Nobody loves the military like check cashers and "payday lenders." They
know that most personnel aren't making a great deal of money; they know
that the government issues paychecks regularly and that the checks are
good.
___
"Payday lenders" loan $40 billion a year and collect $6 billion in interest,
according to the Consumer Federation of America. We used to call people
like these loan sharks. Now we call them "payday lenders."
___
Somehow, "payday lenders" got the state law rewritten for them in 1999
to allow them to charge usurious interest rates.
___
As a result, a finance company, charging 24 percent to 48 percent interest
can't operate in Arkansas, but a so-called "payday lender" can regularly
charge about 400 percent annual interest.
___
The trick is, the law that enables them to operate declares that the
loans they make aren't loans and the interest they charge isn't interest.
___
Therefore, they aren't regulated by the laws governing loans and interest
and they are not technically guilty of usury. If your neighbor beat
you severely with a ball bat, but called it a deep tissue massage, could
he escape the consequences of his action? We don't know what the legislators
were thinking when they decided in 1999 that these unprincipled lenders
could gouge the low-income and needy.
___
The only state senators to vote against that law were Mike Beebe, now
the attorney general, and Mike Ross, now a U.S. congressman. But we
do know that a coalition of consumer groups has organized to change
the lawgroups including the Arkansas Federal Credit Union, Arkansas
Advocates for Children and Families, the Consumer Federation of America,
ACORN, AARP, the Better Business Bureau and the Cooperative Extension
Service. We know that the Family Support Center at Little Rock Air Force
Base alerts airmen and their families to the problems with "payday lenders."
___
Now that there is a local coalition, headquartered right in front of
the air base, we would hope base officials would send a representative
or liaison to Arkansans Against Abusive Payday Lending.
___
And there is no longer any excuse for the state's senators and representatives
to plead ignorance on this issue. We call on our area representatives
to right this wrong in the January session of the General Assembly and
outlaw "payday" lending.
|